Winter 2011 Issue

Categories:

Ideas and the Public Domain: Revisiting INS v. AP in the Internet Age
by Andrew Beckerman-Rodau

ABSTRACT: The integration of the Internet into all aspects of society has led to the quick and widespread distribution of information in digital form. This digital information can be easily aggregated and redistributed by third parties. Such information aggregators can free ride on the work of others. For example, Google News collects links to news stories from other news outlets. Blogs, Facebook, Twitter and other social media also enable redistribution of news stories and other information. Newspapers, wire services and other news creators and providers have voiced concern that such free riding allows aggregators to benefit from the work of enterprises that create news media without having to pay any of the costs to obtain such news stories. It has been asserted that free riding is unfair and that it can economically injure or destroy such enterprises. These concerns are reminiscent of the 1918 Supreme Court decision in International News Service v. Associated Press, in which a news organization successfully enjoined a competitor from free riding on its efforts to obtain news stories. The underlying basis for the Court’s decision was a federal common law action for misappropriation. Although a subsequent Supreme Court decision negated federal common law some states adopted the misappropriation doctrine from International News Service under state unfair competition law. This doctrine has been asserted with limited success but courts continue to hold that the doctrine is viable under appropriate facts. This Article will critically examine the International News Service decision and subsequent judicial decisions relying on the misappropriation doctrine. It will argue that International News Service has been misunderstood and misapplied; and, that courts should unequivocally repudiate the doctrine as inconsistent with property law. Additionally, the commonly asserted rationales for the doctrine—preventing free riding and ruinous competition—are not legitimate. Instead, any common law action to protect ideas or information should only succeed, if at all, under existing contract and tort causes of action.
Read More 0 Comments

Choking the Channel of Public Information: Re-Examination of an Eighteenth-Century Warning about Copyright and Free Speech
by Edward L. Carter

ABSTRACT: The U.S. Supreme Court in Eldred v. Ashcroft gave First Amendment importance to the topic of copyright history. In measuring whether Congress has altered the “traditional contours” of copyright such that First Amendment scrutiny must be applied, federal courts—including the Supreme Court in its 2011 Term case Golan v. Holder—must carefully examine the intertwined history of copyright and freedom of the press. The famous but misunderstood case of Donaldson v. Beckett in the British House of Lords in 1774 is an important piece of this history. In Donaldson, several lawyers, litigants, judges, and lords recognized the danger posed by copyright to untrammeled public communication. Eighteenth-century newspaper accounts shed new light on the free press implications of this important period in copyright law history.
Read More 1 Comment

Brand Renegades
by Jeremy N. Sheff

ABSTRACT: Recent appearances of trademarks in popular culture—in rap lyrics, on reality TV shows, even in youth riots—have raised the question whether the owners of those trademarks might pursue legal remedies to protect their brands from unwanted social associations. This Article argues that they cannot, and that we should understand this limitation on trademark rights as grounded in a principle that consumption of certain brands is an expressive act that First Amendment principles place outside trademark owners’ control.
Read More 3 Comments

Caught in the Middle: Reducing the Uncertainty Created by the FDA and the Patent System for Genetic Diagnostic Test Makers
by Sharonmoyee Goswami

Caught in the Middle: Reducing the Uncertainty Created by the FDA and the Patent System for Genetic Diagnostic Test Makers
ABSTRACT: The scientific complexity of genetic diagnostic testing produces test results which are often flawed or difficult to interpret. Therefore, increased regulation of these tests is necessary to protect consumers and encourage patient reliance. However, increased regulation is accompanied by increased costs for genetic diagnostic test makers. If such costs are increased with no opportunity for test makers to recoup their investments, the proposed regulations will reduce public access to these genetic tests, and will reduce future innovation in this field. In similar industries, manufacturers can recoup regulatory costs through intellectual property protection—using a patent to prevent competitors from bringing identical products to market. Unfortunately, the law is unclear as to whether genetic diagnostic tests fall within patentable subject matter. Here I suggest five changes that would alleviate consumer concerns while spurring further innovation in the genetic diagnostic test industry: (1) Increase labeling and genetic counseling requirements for direct-to-consumer tests; (2) Provide for statutory data exclusivity (rather than patent protection) for tests that require clinical studies for FDA approval; (3) Create mandatory maximum approval times for certain classes of genetic diagnostic tests to reduce the regulatory burden on manufacturers; (4) Require that manufacturers and regulatory agencies solicit complaints directly from consumers; and (5) Require minimal new regulation for purely software-based genetic diagnostic tests.
Read More 0 Comments

ARCHIVES

Array ( [0] => /var/www/jipel/index.php [1] => /var/www/jipel/wp-blog-header.php [2] => /var/www/jipel/wp-load.php [3] => /var/www/jipel/wp-config.php [4] => /var/www/jipel/wp-settings.php [5] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/load.php [6] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/default-constants.php [7] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/version.php [8] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/compat.php [9] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/functions.php [10] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/option.php [11] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class-wp.php [12] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class-wp-error.php [13] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/plugin.php [14] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/pomo/mo.php [15] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/pomo/translations.php [16] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/pomo/entry.php [17] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/pomo/streams.php [18] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/wp-db.php [19] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/cache.php [20] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/default-filters.php [21] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/l10n.php [22] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class-wp-walker.php [23] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class-wp-ajax-response.php [24] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/formatting.php [25] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/capabilities.php [26] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/query.php [27] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/date.php [28] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/theme.php [29] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class-wp-theme.php [30] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/template.php [31] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/user.php [32] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/meta.php [33] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/general-template.php [34] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/link-template.php [35] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/author-template.php [36] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/post.php [37] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/post-template.php [38] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/revision.php [39] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/post-formats.php [40] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/post-thumbnail-template.php [41] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/category.php [42] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/category-template.php [43] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/comment.php [44] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/comment-template.php [45] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/rewrite.php [46] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/feed.php [47] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/bookmark.php [48] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/bookmark-template.php [49] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/kses.php [50] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/cron.php [51] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/deprecated.php [52] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/script-loader.php [53] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class.wp-dependencies.php [54] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class.wp-scripts.php [55] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/functions.wp-scripts.php [56] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class.wp-styles.php [57] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/functions.wp-styles.php [58] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/taxonomy.php [59] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/update.php [60] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/canonical.php [61] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/shortcodes.php [62] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class-wp-embed.php [63] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/media.php [64] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/http.php [65] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class-http.php [66] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/widgets.php [67] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/nav-menu.php [68] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/nav-menu-template.php [69] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/admin-bar.php [70] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/vars.php [71] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/gravityforms.php [72] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/common.php [73] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/forms_model.php [74] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/widget.php [75] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/includes/api.php [76] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/includes/webapi/webapi.php [77] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/includes/addon/class-gf-addon.php [78] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/akismet/akismet.php [79] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/akismet/class.akismet.php [80] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/akismet/class.akismet-widget.php [81] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/akismet/wrapper.php [82] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/blog-in-blog/blog-in-blog.php [83] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/blog-in-blog/options.php [84] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/blog-in-blog/plugin-meta/plugin-meta.php [85] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/blog-in-blog/plugin-meta/markdown.php [86] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/configure-smtp/configure-smtp.php [87] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/configure-smtp/c2c-plugin.php [88] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/custom-sidebars/customsidebars.php [89] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/enable-media-replace/enable-media-replace.php [90] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/exclude-pages/exclude_pages.php [91] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/footnotes/index.php [92] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/footnotes/includes/defines.php [93] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/footnotes/includes/language.php [94] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/footnotes/includes/plugin-settings.php [95] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/footnotes/includes/scripts.php [96] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/footnotes/includes/convert.php [97] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/footnotes/includes/wysiwyg-editor.php [98] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/footnotes/includes/replacer.php [99] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/footnotes/classes/footnotes.php [100] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/footnotes/classes/footnotes_settings.php [101] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/footnotes/classes/footnotes_widget.php [102] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/jquery-collapse-o-matic/collapse-o-matic.php [103] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/posts-in-sidebar/posts-in-sidebar.php [104] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/posts-in-sidebar/posts-in-sidebar-widget.php [105] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/posts-in-sidebar/widget-form-functions.php [106] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/search-unleashed/search-unleashed.php [107] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/search-unleashed/plugin.php [108] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/search-unleashed/models/widget.php [109] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/simple-term-meta/simple-term-meta.php [110] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/single-post-template/post_templates.php [111] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/ssh-sftp-updater-support/sftp.php [112] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/trackable-social-share-icons/index.php [113] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/wp-table-reloaded/wp-table-reloaded.php [114] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/wp-table-reloaded/controllers/controller-frontend.php [115] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/wp-table-reloaded/controllers/controller-base.php [116] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/pluggable.php [117] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/pluggable-deprecated.php [118] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/default-widgets.php [119] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/locale.php [120] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/jipel/functions.php [121] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions.php [122] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-init.php [123] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-functions.php [124] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-setup.php [125] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-custom.php [126] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-interface.php [127] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-framework-settings.php [128] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-seo.php [129] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-sbm.php [130] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-medialibrary-uploader.php [131] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-hooks.php [132] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-shortcodes.php [133] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-shortcode-generator.php [134] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-backup.php [135] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/theme-options.php [136] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/theme-functions.php [137] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/theme-plugins.php [138] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/theme-actions.php [139] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/theme-comments.php [140] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/theme-js.php [141] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/sidebar-init.php [142] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/theme-widgets.php [143] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-tabs.php [144] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-adspace.php [145] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-blogauthor.php [146] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-embed.php [147] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-flickr.php [148] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-search.php [149] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-twitter.php [150] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-subscribe.php [151] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-gallery.php [152] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-ad125.php [153] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/woo-column-generator/woo-column-generator.php [154] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/template-loader.php [155] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/jipel/archive.php [156] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/jipel/header.php [157] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/form_display.php [158] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/sidebar.php [159] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/jipel/footer.php )