Ledger Spring 2011 Issue

Patent Eligibility of Molecules: “Product of Nature” Doctrine After Myriad
by Can Cui

ABSTRACT: In March 2010, the U.S. District Court in the Southern District of New York held in the Myriad case that patent claims directed to isolated DNA molecules were invalid under 35 U.S.C. § 101 for failing to claim patent-eligible subject matter, relying heavily on the so-called “product of nature” doctrine.  Instead of a chronological order, this Note reviews the legal history of the “product of nature” doctrine in a brand new analytical framework, analyzing the application of the “product of nature” doctrine to relevant cases based on whether the claimed subject matter is an element, a molecule, or a microorganism.
Read More 0 Comments

Substantial Disparity: Copyright Chaos in the Second Circuit
by Graham Ballou

ABSTRACT: The test for substantial similarity is a doctrinal mess.  In response, recent commentators have called for the inclusion of expert testimony at this stage of an infringement analysis.  Graham Ballou, however, argues that judicial latitude in the framing of the inquiry is more responsible for jury confusion than a lack of expert witnesses.  After surveying three years of summary judgment opinions on substantial similarity from district courts in the Second Circuit, Ballou concludes that copyright law should discourage summary judgment on and de novo review of substantial similarity, therefore re-empowering the jury on the inherently subjective question of improper appropriation.
Read More 0 Comments

You May Not “Like” This Title: Everything Stored On Facebook Is Discoverable
by Darren A. Heitner

ABSTRACT: Facebook has revolutionized the way that people communicate and do business by providing an open and connected environment for individuals and businesses alike. This openness has largely contributed to both its popularity and success. However, enjoying the openness of this revolutionary platform may come at an unexpected cost, especially for those who do not understand how the website’s content may be used as evidence in a lawsuit. Darren Heitner demonstrates how content published on a person’s Facebook account may be discoverable for the purposes of litigation, even when the information sought is unavailable through Facebook’s privacy settings.
Read More 0 Comments

What Are The Constitutional Limits On Awards Of Statutory Damages?
by Andrew Berger

ABSTRACT: Music piracy is a major problem in this country, robbing the economy of billions each year. Andrew Berger argues that, if piracy is to end, large verdicts of the kind awarded in Sony BMG Music Entertainment et al. v. Tenenbaum may be necessary. In Tenenbaum, the first file sharing case ever to reach an appellate court following trial, the court held that the jury’s statutory damages award violated the Due Process Clause, even though the award was within the statutory range set by Congress. Berger discusses the ways in which this decision could negatively impact copyright enforcement for years to come.
Read More 0 Comments

ARCHIVES

Array ( [0] => /var/www/jipel/index.php [1] => /var/www/jipel/wp-blog-header.php [2] => /var/www/jipel/wp-load.php [3] => /var/www/jipel/wp-config.php [4] => /var/www/jipel/wp-settings.php [5] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/load.php [6] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/default-constants.php [7] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/version.php [8] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/compat.php [9] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/functions.php [10] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class-wp.php [11] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class-wp-error.php [12] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/plugin.php [13] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/wp-db.php [14] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/cache.php [15] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/default-filters.php [16] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/pomo/mo.php [17] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/pomo/translations.php [18] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/pomo/entry.php [19] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/pomo/streams.php [20] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/l10n.php [21] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class-wp-walker.php [22] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class-wp-ajax-response.php [23] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/formatting.php [24] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/capabilities.php [25] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/query.php [26] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/theme.php [27] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/user.php [28] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/meta.php [29] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/general-template.php [30] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/link-template.php [31] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/author-template.php [32] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/post.php [33] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/post-template.php [34] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/category.php [35] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/category-template.php [36] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/comment.php [37] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/comment-template.php [38] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/rewrite.php [39] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/feed.php [40] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/bookmark.php [41] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/bookmark-template.php [42] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/kses.php [43] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/cron.php [44] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/deprecated.php [45] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/script-loader.php [46] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class.wp-dependencies.php [47] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class.wp-scripts.php [48] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/functions.wp-scripts.php [49] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class.wp-styles.php [50] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/functions.wp-styles.php [51] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/taxonomy.php [52] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/update.php [53] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/canonical.php [54] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/shortcodes.php [55] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/media.php [56] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/http.php [57] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/class-http.php [58] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/widgets.php [59] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/nav-menu.php [60] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/nav-menu-template.php [61] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/admin-bar.php [62] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/vars.php [63] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/exclude-pages/exclude_pages.php [64] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/gravityforms.php [65] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/common.php [66] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/forms_model.php [67] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/widget.php [68] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/search-unleashed/search-unleashed.php [69] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/search-unleashed/plugin.php [70] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/search-unleashed/models/widget.php [71] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/simple-term-meta/simple-term-meta.php [72] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/ssh-sftp-updater-support/sftp.php [73] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/trackable-social-share-icons/index.php [74] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/wp-table-reloaded/wp-table-reloaded.php [75] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/wp-table-reloaded/controllers/controller-frontend.php [76] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/wp-table-reloaded/controllers/controller-base.php [77] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/pluggable.php [78] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/pluggable-deprecated.php [79] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/default-widgets.php [80] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/locale.php [81] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/jipel/functions.php [82] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions.php [83] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-init.php [84] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-functions.php [85] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-setup.php [86] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-custom.php [87] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-interface.php [88] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-framework-settings.php [89] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-seo.php [90] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-sbm.php [91] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-medialibrary-uploader.php [92] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-hooks.php [93] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-shortcodes.php [94] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-shortcode-generator.php [95] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/functions/admin-backup.php [96] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/theme-options.php [97] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/theme-functions.php [98] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/theme-plugins.php [99] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/theme-actions.php [100] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/theme-comments.php [101] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/theme-js.php [102] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/sidebar-init.php [103] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/theme-widgets.php [104] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-tabs.php [105] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-adspace.php [106] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-blogauthor.php [107] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-embed.php [108] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-flickr.php [109] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-search.php [110] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-twitter.php [111] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-subscribe.php [112] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-gallery.php [113] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/widgets/widget-woo-ad125.php [114] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/includes/woo-column-generator/woo-column-generator.php [115] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/post-thumbnail-template.php [116] => /var/www/jipel/wp-includes/template-loader.php [117] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/jipel/archive.php [118] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/jipel/header.php [119] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/plugins/gravityforms/form_display.php [120] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/editorial/sidebar.php [121] => /var/www/jipel/wp-content/themes/jipel/footer.php )